Summary of Article with a Stated Thesis

Before beginning this exercise, review the guidelines below for writing a one-paragraph summary.

1.      As you read the article, underline the first and last sentences of each paragraph.

  1. Examine the first paragraph, which – in most essays – will be the introductory paragraph. The first sentence should reveal the general topic, and the final sentence should contain the essay’s thesis and pattern of organization.
  2. Look at the first and last sentences of subsequent paragraphs. Do their first sentences appear to be main points that support your tentative thesis? If they do not, you may have to infer the paragraphs’ topics. If the initial sentence of the final paragraph appears to paraphrase the thesis contained in the introductory paragraph, this will be the concluding paragraph.
  3. As you reread the body paragraphs, look for major supports. Number them. Exclude minor supports because they contain details, e.g. examples, statistics, etc.
  4. Reread the article again. Without looking at the original article, write a paragraph based on the reading. It should include the article’s thesis, main points, and major supports. Be sure to include the original article’s title and author.
  5. Compare what you have written to what you have underlined and numbered. Be sure that you have included the thesis of the article as well as the main points and major supports in the order they are listed in the article and your outline. Ensure that you have not included details.
  6. Edit your paragraph for grammatical and mechanical errors. Be sure that you use a variety of sentence structures.

 

Step 1

Directions: As you read the article, outline the last sentence of the introduction and the first and last sentences of subsequent paragraphs.

Alzheimer’s Disease

Alzheimer’s disease is a progressive, degenerative and irreversible brain disorder. It is estimated that 2-5 percent of people over 65 years of age and up to 20 percent of those over 80 years of age suffer from the disease. Although there have been advances made in the control of this disease through drugs, it has no definite cure. Patients with Alzheimer’s disease suffer from disorientation and intellectual and psychological impairment which eventually lead to death. The exact cause of the disease is still unknown. However, it has been associated with certain causes that merit to be studied, as they lead to devastating and sometimes fatal consequences.

Various theories have linked the disease to a number of other causes. It is believed that the disease can be inherited. People who have a parent or sibling with Alzheimer’s disease were found to be five times more likely to develop the disease as compared to those who did not. Some believe that highly chemically reactive oxygen molecules, known as free radicals, may be the cause. These, which have been blamed for heart disease and cancer, may lead to Alzheimer’s. In addition, other theories claim that physical trauma, such as whiplash injuries, or the body’s immune system may be the culprit.

Alzheimer’s disease is linked to the gradual formation of plaque in the brain, particularly in the hippocampus and adjoining cortex. As the disease develops, it destroys chemical messages used by the cells of the brain to communicate with each other. It is though that the disease either disrupts the production of an important neurotransmitter known as acetylcholine or stimulates the over-production of the enzyme cholinesterase, which eliminates the former, thus, hindering its performance.

The rate of decline in Alzheimer patients varies from patient to patient. The disease course runs anywhere from three to 20 years, with eight years being the average life span after diagnosis. However, there are some well-established features of the disease that can be observed during its course. The Alzheimer patient suffers from disorientation to time and place and has difficulty in performing difficult tasks. Some of the more noticeable symptoms are problems with memory, abstract thinking, and language. In addition to suffering from decreased judgment and changes in mood and behaviour, an Alzheimer patient may suffer from sleep disturbance, anxiety, and depression.

Adapted from BBC News Online Health, October 15, 2000

Step 2

Directions:  Examine the first paragraph, which – in most essays – will be the introductory paragraph. The first sentence should reveal the general topic, and the final sentence should contain the essay’s thesis and pattern of organization.

Alzheimer’s disease is a progressive, degenerative and irreversible brain disorder. It is estimated that 2-5 percent of people over 65 years of age and up to 20 percent of those over 80 years of age suffer from the disease. Although there have been advances made in the control of this disease through drugs, it has no definite cure. Patients with Alzheimer’s disease suffer from disorientation and intellectual and psychological impairment which eventually lead to death. The exact cause of the disease is still unknown. However, it has been associated with certain causes that merit to be studied, as they lead to devastating and sometimes fatal consequences.

1.       The general topic of this essay is probably _____.

a.       brain disorders

b.       elderly people

c.       Alzheimer’s disease

2.       The pattern of organization is probably _____.

a.       definition

b.       cause and effect

c.       process

3.       The thesis is probably _____.

a.       Brain disorders can be defined according to etiology and symptoms.

b.       Elderly people are likely candidates for Alzheimer’s disease.

c.       The devastating effects of Alzheimer’s disease can be linked to several possible causes.

Step 3

Directions:  Look at the first and last sentences of subsequent paragraphs. Do their first sentences appear to be main points that support your tentative thesis? If the initial sentence of the final paragraph appears to paraphrase the thesis contained in the introductory paragraph, this will be the concluding paragraph.

Various theories have linked the disease to a number of other causes. It is believed that the disease can be inherited. People who have a parent or sibling with Alzheimer’s disease were found to be five times more likely to develop the disease as compared to those who did not. Some believe that highly chemically reactive oxygen molecules, known as free radicals, may be the cause. These, which have been blamed for heart disease and cancer, may lead to Alzheimer’s. In addition, other theories claim that physical trauma, such as whiplash injuries, or the body’s immune system may be the culprit.

4.       The topic of this paragraph is _____.

a.       There are three specific causes of Alzheimer’s disease.

b.       Although scientists are unsure of its specific etiology, they have linked it to three possible causes.

c.       People whose family members have Alzheimer’s disease are five times more likely to develop it compared to those who do not.

5.       Is this a main point that supports the article’s thesis?

a.       Yes

b.       No

Alzheimer’s disease is linked to the gradual formation of plaque in the brain, particularly in the hippocampus and adjoining cortex. As the disease develops, it destroys chemical messages used by the cells of the brain to communicate with each other. It is though that the disease either disrupts the production of an important neurotransmitter known as acetylcholine or stimulates the over-production of the enzyme cholinesterase, which eliminates the former, thus, hindering its performance.

6.       The topic of this paragraph is _____.

a.       Plaque formation is a cause of Alzheimer’s disease.

b.       One effect of Alzheimer’s disease is plaque formation in the brain.

c.       Chemicals messages are necessary for communication in the brain.

7.       Is this a main point that supports the article’s thesis?

a.       Yes

b.       No

The rate of decline in Alzheimer patients varies from patient to patient. The disease course runs anywhere from three to 20 years, with eight years being the average life span after diagnosis. However, there are some well-established features of the disease that can be observed during its course. The Alzheimer patient suffers from disorientation to time and place and has difficulty in performing difficult tasks. Some of the more noticeable symptoms are problems with memory, abstract thinking, and language. In addition to suffering from decreased judgment and changes in mood and behaviour, an Alzheimer patient may suffer from sleep disturbance, anxiety, and depression.

8.       Based on the reading, what can you logically infer as the topic of this paragraph?

a.       Alzheimer’s disease leads to two effects.

b.       Alzheimer patients live from three to 20 years.

c.       Alzheimer patients are disoriented and have other mental problems.

9.       Is this a main point that supports the article’s thesis, or is this a restatement of the thesis contained in the introduction?

a.       main point that supports the article’s thesis

b.       restatement of the thesis contained in the introduction

Step 4

Directions:  As you reread the body paragraphs, look for major supports.

1Various theories have linked the disease to a number of other causes. 2It is believed that the disease can be inherited. 3People who have a parent or sibling with Alzheimer’s disease were found to be five times more likely to develop the disease as compared to those who did not. 4Some believe that highly chemically reactive oxygen molecules, known as free radicals, may be the cause. 5These, which have been blamed for heart disease and cancer, may lead to Alzheimer’s. 6In addition, other theories claim that physical trauma, such as whiplash injuries, or the body’s immune system may be the culprit.

10.   How many possible causes (major supports) are identified?

a.       2

b.       3

c.       4

11.   What are the possible causes?

a.       siblings, free radicals, heart disease, and cancer

b.       inheritance, free radicals, and whiplash

c.        inheritance, free radicals, and physical trauma

12.   Which sentences should be excluded because they include details?

a.       sentences 1 and 2

b.       sentences 3 and 4

c.       sentences 3 and 5

1Alzheimer’s disease is linked to the gradual formation of plaque in the brain, particularly in the hippocampus and adjoining cortex. 2As the disease develops, it destroys chemical messages used by the cells of the brain to communicate with each other. 3It is though that the disease either disrupts the production of an important neurotransmitter known as acetylcholine or stimulates the over-production of the enzyme cholinesterase, which eliminates the former, thus, hindering its performance.

13.   How many effects (major supports) are identified?

a.       2

b.       3

c.       1

14.   What are the effects?

a.       formation of the hippocampus and adjoining cortex

b.       chemical destruction, plaque formation, over-production of cholinesterase

c.       destruction of chemical messages in the brain

15.   Which sentences should be excluded because they include details?

a.       sentence 1

b.       sentence 2

c.       sentence 3

1The rate of decline in Alzheimer patients varies from patient to patient. 2The disease course runs anywhere from three to 20 years, with eight years being the average life span after diagnosis. 3However, there are some well-established features of the disease that can be observed during its course. 4The Alzheimer patient suffers from disorientation to time and place and has difficulty in performing difficult tasks. 5Some of the more noticeable symptoms are problems with memory, abstract thinking, and language. 6In addition to suffering from decreased judgment and changes in mood and behaviour, an Alzheimer patient may suffer from sleep disturbance, anxiety, and depression.

16.   How many effects (major supports) are identified?

a.       1

b.       2

c.       3

17.   What are the effects?

a.       life expectancy

b.       life expectancy and mental symptoms

c.       life expectancy, mental symptoms, and depression

18.   Which sentence contains details that should be excluded?

a.       sentence 1

b.       sentence 2

c.       sentence 3

Step 5

Directions:  Without looking the outlined sentences, write a paragraph based on your outline. It should include the article’s thesis, main points, and major supports. Be sure to include the original article’s title and author.

19.   Which of the following paragraphs best summarizes the original article?

a.       The three possible causes of Alzheimer’s disease lead to devastating effects. Although scientists are currently unsure of its specific etiology, they have linked Alzheimer’s disease to three possible causes. Possible culprits are inheritance, free radicals, and physical trauma. While the causes are uncertain, there are clearly identifiable effects. As plaque in the brain continues to form, neural cell communication is destroyed. The destruction is due to either disruption/under-production of acetylcholine or over-production of cholinesterase. Although progression of the disease varies in patients, certain features are clear. Their cognitive and oral skills gradually deteriorate, as do their moods.

b.       In “Alzheimer’s Disease,” the unknown author discusses the possible causes of this progressively degenerative brain disorder and their devastating effects on its victims. This disease affects at least 20 percent of elderly people who are over 80 years old. Although scientists are currently unsure of its specific etiology, they have linked Alzheimer’s disease to three possible causes. Possible culprits are inheritance, free radicals, and physical trauma. While the causes are uncertain, there are clearly identifiable effects. As plaque in the brain continues to form, neural cell communication is destroyed. The destruction is due to either disruption/under-production of acetylcholine or over-production of cholinesterase. Although progression of the disease varies in patients, certain features are clear. Their cognitive and oral skills gradually deteriorate, as do their moods.

c.       In “Alzheimer’s Disease,” the unknown author discusses the possible causes of this progressively degenerative brain disorder and their devastating effects on its victims. Although scientists are currently unsure of its specific etiology, they have linked Alzheimer’s disease to three possible causes. Possible culprits are inheritance, free radicals, and physical trauma. While the causes are uncertain, there are clearly identifiable effects. As plaque in the brain continues to form, chemical cell communication in the brain is destroyed. Although progression of the disease varies in patients, there are additional effects of Alzheimer’s. The average life expectancy after diagnosis is eight years. In addition, certain symptoms related to deterioration of cognitive skills appear. Patients’ memories and behavior gradually deteriorate, as do their moods.

d.       In “Alzheimer’s Disease,” the unknown author discusses the possible causes of this progressively degenerative brain disorder and their devastating effects on its victims. Although scientists are currently unsure of its specific etiology, they have linked Alzheimer’s disease to three possible causes. Possible culprits are inheritance, free radicals, and physical trauma. The destruction is due to either disruption/under-production of acetylcholine or over-production of cholinesterase. Although progression of the disease varies in patients, certain features are clear. Their cognitive and oral skills gradually deteriorate, as do their moods. While the causes are uncertain, there are clearly identifiable effects. As plaque in the brain continues to form, neural cell communication is destroyed.

20.   Referring to question 19, why is this the best summary?

a.       It contains the name of the article’s title and author.

b.       It contains the thesis, main points, and major supports of the original article, but it does not contain minor points.

c.       All information is presented in the order they are listed in the original article.

d.       All of the above